The Date That Almost Didn't Happen
It was a Thursday night in East Nashville, about six years before Lila was even a thought. I'd been working at Bonobos for a few years, helping guys find the perfect first-date outfit, telling them exactly what to wear to make a good impression.
I should have taken my own advice.
Brooke had agreed to meet me for dinner at a little Italian place on the east side. I'd been crushing on her for weeks — she taught fourth grade at a school near the shop, and she'd come in once to buy a gift for her brother. She was smart, funny, and had this way of looking at you like you were the only person in the room.
I was nervous. Which is probably why I overthought everything.
The Mistake
I wanted to look impressive. I wanted to look like I had my life together. I wanted to look like the guy she'd want to see again.
So I did what so many guys do: I tried too hard.
The Outfit I Wore:
A navy suit jacket that was a little too structured
A crisp white dress shirt, buttoned all the way up
A pair of dark trousers that were a little too formal
Shiny oxfords that I'd just polished
A tie that I had spent twenty minutes perfecting
I looked like I was going to a job interview. Or a funeral. Definitely not a first date.
I walked into that restaurant like I was walking into a boardroom. Shoulders tight, smile forced, tie adjusted three times before we even ordered drinks.
Brooke, on the other hand, looked like she'd been doing this her whole life.
What Brooke Wore
She wore a simple black dress — nothing fancy, nothing expensive, just a well-fitting dress that she'd probably owned for years. A pair of comfortable ankle boots. A small silver necklace that I later learned was her grandmother's. Her hair was down, slightly wavy, like she'd just walked in from the breeze.
She looked effortless. She looked like herself.
I asked her about it later, after we'd been dating for a few months. I said, "That first night, you looked so put together. How long did it take you to get ready?"
She laughed. "About ten minutes. I just wore what I liked. I wasn't trying to impress anyone."
That sentence hit me harder than she probably realized.
What I Learned
Lesson 1: Comfort Is Confidence
I spent the whole night adjusting my tie and checking my jacket. I was so uncomfortable that I couldn't relax. I couldn't be myself.
Brooke, meanwhile, was comfortable in what she was wearing. Which meant she was comfortable in the conversation. She could focus on me, not on her clothes.
The Takeaway: If you're not comfortable in what you're wearing, you're not going to be comfortable on the date.
Lesson 2: Trying Too Hard Shows
I thought I was impressing Brooke by looking polished. What I actually did was look like I was trying to impress her. There's a difference.
The Takeaway: Effortless is attractive. Trying too hard reads as insecurity.
Lesson 3: She Wasn't Looking at the Outfit
Here's the thing I forgot in all my nervousness: Brooke wasn't evaluating my outfit. She was evaluating me.
She didn't care if my tie was straight or if my shoes were polished. She cared if I was interesting, if I made her laugh, if I was kind to the waiter.
The Takeaway: Your clothes are important. But they're not the most important thing.
Lesson 4: Fit First (Even on a Date)
The irony is that my suit jacket was structured and uncomfortable because it didn't fit right. It was a size too big in the shoulders, which made me feel boxy and stiff. If I'd worn something that actually fit — something more relaxed and natural — I probably would have felt more like myself.
The Takeaway: Fit matters. But the right fit isn't the one that makes you look impressive. It's the one that makes you feel like you.
The Second Date
I got a second date. Barely. Brooke told me later that she almost said no because I looked too serious.
I changed it up.
I wore dark jeans, a simple henley, and a pair of boots I'd worn a hundred times. No tie. No structured jacket. Just clothes that felt like me.
Brooke told me later, "You looked like a different person. You looked comfortable. I liked that."
The Weddings and the Kids
We got married a year later. Brooke wore a simple white dress that she'd found at a vintage shop. I wore a navy suit — the same navy suit I've worn to every important event since, the one I wrote about in the "One Suit, Five Ways" post.
At the wedding, I didn't overthink it. I didn't try to impress anyone. I just put on the suit that fit, walked down the aisle, and married the best person I know.
Six years later, we've got Lila, a house in East Nashville, a brick pizza oven in the backyard, and a thousand other reasons to be grateful.
Brooke still wears what she likes. She still looks effortless. And I still try to keep up.
The Advice I Give Now
When guys come to me asking what to wear on a first date, I tell them the same thing:
Wear something you've worn before. Not new. Not "special." Something you know fits and feels right.
Don't dress for the occasion. Dress for yourself. If you feel like yourself, you'll act like yourself.
Skip the tie. Unless it's truly a formal occasion, the tie makes you look like you're trying too hard.
Fit the clothes, not the other way around. If your jacket is too tight or your pants are too long, you'll spend the whole date thinking about your clothes instead of the person across from you.
Remember that she's not evaluating you. She's just trying to see if you're interesting. Be interesting.
The Conversation
A few weeks ago, Lila asked Brooke and me about our first date. She's ten now, so she's starting to understand these things.
Brooke told her, "Your dad wore a tie. He was very serious."
I said, "I was nervous. I wanted to impress her."
Lila looked at me. "But you didn't need to impress her, Dad. She already liked you."
Out of the mouths of babes.
Lila's right. Brooke already liked me. She didn't need me to be impressive. She just needed me to be myself.
Fit First. The Rest Is Noise.
I spend a lot of time on this blog talking about fit. The shoulder seam, the collar, the break in the pants. All of that matters.
But here's what matters more: wearing clothes that feel like you. Clothes that don't distract from who you are.
Brooke knew that from day one. I'm still learning.
No letters yet — pray write the first.